When I was growing up, I loved Whatchamacallit until they added caramel to it. A few years ago my favorite candy bar was Bar None -- a chocolate lover's delight! Until they added caramel to it. My current favorite is ReeseSticks. They're probably planning on adding caramel to that next week.

In some semblance of order:
ReeseSticks
Twix (peanut butter ones)
Royals (which was an M&Mish candy, but they had a hint of mint under the candy coating. I don't think they exist anymore.)
Krackel (slightly better than Nestle Crunch)
M&Ms with Almonds (yummy!)
PB Max (before they added caramel to them. Like Royals, I don't think they exist anymore.)
Kit Kat (but I get tired of it by the third stick)
oo... Tolberone (which I also loved back when I lived in Germany)

Oh, and Bar None, even after adding caramel, seems to have vanished. It has come back in another form called "Hershey's Sweet Escapes triple chocolate wafer bar" (in their reduced fat candy bar line), but doesn't taste as good.

- Faux "Ick! Coconut!" Pas